At ten o'clock in the evening, Hogwarts Castle fell silent. Due to the curfew, the corridors were empty, save for the low murmur of voices from the portraits on the walls.
Then, not far away, a sudden flash of light appeared. A door had been opened, and the glow from within spilled out. The quiet sound of stone grinding against the floor followed, accompanied by the footsteps of a lone figure.
Harry took a few steps forward but couldn't help glancing back at the Gargoyle, which had hopped back into place. He let out a long, melancholy sigh.
He had tried to bargain with Dumbledore—offering Slughorn's memory in exchange for being spared detention, something he had been certain would work—but it had completely backfired.
"I'm glad you got the memory, Harry. If you like, I'll give you an extra reward, but it won't help you avoid punishment. Those are two separate matters that cannot be easily offset," Dumbledore had told him.
That meant he still had to report to Professor McGonagall's office every Saturday for detention, which also meant missing the final and most crucial Quidditch match.
The only small consolation was that Kyle seemed to have other commitments and wouldn't be playing in the match either.
With only one game left in the season, Hufflepuff and Gryffindor were neck and neck, separated by a mere ten points. In other words, whoever scored higher in the final match would likely take the championship.
Now that both teams had lost a key player, the playing field was, in a way, evened out.
"I hope Kyle still doesn't play," Harry sighed, then turned and headed toward the common room.
At this hour, there weren't many students left in the common room, but Hermione and Ron were still there, looking as though they had been waiting for him the entire time.
"What took you so long?"
"So, did Headmaster Dumbledore expel you?" Hermione asked.
"No," Harry shook his head. "But he docked me a hundred points, and I have to serve detention every Saturday in Professor McGonagall's office."
"As long as you're not expelled," Ron said, taking it in stride. "Losing points and getting detention is nothing. Our house is already last in the rankings—another hundred points won't make much of a difference."
"It's not about the points," Harry replied. "It's the fact that I have to be in detention every Saturday."
"So what? You... wait a minute." Ron suddenly realized something. "You mean every Saturday?"
"That's right."
"What about the final Quidditch match?" Ron asked urgently.
"I can't help it," Harry said with a shrug.
"How can the headmaster do that..." Ron said, growing anxious. "That match will decide whether we win the Quidditch Cup!"
"Can you go back and talk to him again? Maybe he'll agree to let you play."
"Don't be ridiculous, Ron," Hermione said, pushing him away. "Do you think the headmaster's decisions are like homework? Something you can just redo until you get a better result?"
"But Gryffindor hasn't won the Quidditch Cup in over ten years," Ron said helplessly, staring up at the ceiling. "This was our best chance!"
"I can't do anything about it," Harry said, lowering his head.
"Never mind that for now," Hermione interrupted as both boys let out long sighs. "How did it go with the memory? Did you give it to Dumbledore?"
"Of course. Thanks to you, Hermione—without you, I don't think I could have gotten it," Harry said.
"That's because you were the one who convinced him," Hermione pointed out. "The Felix Felicis only helped set the mood. If it had been me or Ron, we wouldn't have gotten Professor Slughorn's memory, even if we'd drunk a whole pint of it."
"But setting the mood was exactly what I lacked," Harry admitted. "Anyway, thank you. As for the Felix Felicis, I'll find a way to repay you."
"What are you talking about? You don't need to repay me," Hermione said. "But what exactly was in the memory?"
"I was about to tell you," Harry said, suddenly lowering his voice. "Follow me."
He led them to a secluded row of armchairs in the far corner of the common room and sat down, speaking in hushed tones.
"Slughorn told Voldemort how to make a Horcrux."
"So it really was him?" Hermione gasped, covering her mouth in shock.
"Yeah. He's the one who explained to Voldemort that creating a Horcrux requires committing murder to split one's soul."
Harry then recounted everything he had seen in the memory.
Truthfully, the memory itself wasn't long—just a ten-minute conversation between Slughorn and a young Tom Riddle. But after viewing it, Dumbledore had spent over half an hour deep in thought before finally showing an expression that was both relieved and excited.
After hearing Harry's description, Ron couldn't help but ask, "You mean, Dumbledore looked happy?"
"I think so," Harry nodded. "He even muttered a few words to himself."
"What did he say?" Hermione asked.
"Let me see..." Harry frowned, trying to recall Dumbledore's expression after he had come back to his senses. "He said... 'This memory confirms my suspicions. I was right. I'm so close... Tom, Tom, you never expected this, did you?' Something like that."
"Who is this Tom?" Ron asked, puzzled.
"It's Voldemort's name when he was young," Harry said. "I remember telling you that before. Voldemort's real name is Tom Riddle."
"If you could call him something else, maybe I'd remember," Ron muttered.
His legs always trembled at the mention of "Voldemort," so how could he possibly remember anything Harry had said after that?
"You can't do that, Ron. Be brave. It's just a name," Harry said seriously. "You need to learn to live with it."
"Ah, yeah, I'll try," Ron said, though his tone carried a hint of resignation.
Adapting to calling Voldemort by his name? Easier said than done. He was certain that at least 80% of the wizarding world couldn't do it.
"I'm so close..." Hermione, who had been quiet until now, sat in the armchair, looking at Harry with doubt. "What does that mean?"
"I don't know. Professor Dumbledore didn't say," Harry shook his head. "After that, he let me go and told me to meet him in the Great Hall at seven o'clock tomorrow morning. He said he'd show me something different then... as a reward for getting the memory."
"Hermione," Harry suddenly said, turning to her. "Why don't you come tomorrow morning? Without your Felix Felicis potion, I wouldn't have gotten the memory back, so the reward should go to you."
"No, Harry," Hermione shook her head. "As I said earlier, you were the main factor in convincing Professor Slughorn, and the Felix Felicis only played a supporting role. The reward should go to you."
The two of them were passing the honor back and forth?
"But—"
Harry was about to say more, but Hermione cut him off.
"It's settled, then," she said, standing up. "And you'll probably be in the Headmaster's Office for an hour or two each time. Who knows if it'll be the same tomorrow? The first lesson tomorrow morning is Transfiguration, and I don't want to be late."
"Okay," Harry said, seeing that Hermione was firm in her decision. "If you change your mind, just let me know."
"I won't," Hermione said decisively, waving her hand.
With that, the three of them headed back to their dormitories.
The next morning.
Harry groggily got out of bed and yawned as he made his way toward the Great Hall. Since his second year, he had rarely woken up this early, and he wasn't used to it.
From a distance, he saw Dumbledore standing there, accompanied by... Kyle?
Apparently, after many missed opportunities, Dumbledore had finally managed to catch Kyle on the first morning after the holidays.
He had timed it perfectly, arriving just as Kyle finished breakfast and was about to head to the eighth floor.
"Professor Dumbledore," Harry said, trotting over. "Kyle, you're here too."
"Hello, Harry," Kyle said, then glanced at Dumbledore. "So, he's the one we've been waiting for?"
"That's right," Dumbledore nodded. "I hope you can forgive me for taking the liberty."
"That's fine," Kyle said, then hesitated before changing the subject. "But... never mind. Would you like some breakfast first?"
He had initially wanted to say that Harry hadn't taken Ancient Runes and wouldn't understand anything, but since he was already here, there was no point in mentioning it.
"Breakfast?" Harry touched his stomach.
He was a bit hungry, but he didn't want Kyle and Dumbledore to wait for him. After thinking about it for a moment, he grabbed two sandwiches, deciding to eat while walking so he wouldn't waste time.
The three of them made their way back to the eighth floor together. Kyle led the way, taking a few turns before stopping in a corridor.
Harry knew exactly where they were. He was about to remind Kyle that the Room of Requirement was broken and no one could get in when he saw Kyle take out a strange doorknob and press it against the wall.
The next second, a door suddenly appeared.
The Room of Requirement?
Harry stood there, dumbfounded, staring at the scene in disbelief.
What's going on? Does the Room of Requirement need a key to open now?
He had never heard of such a thing.
And where was this key made? He wanted one too.
It wasn't until the others had stepped through the door that Harry snapped out of his daze and hurriedly followed.
Then, he was shocked again.
He felt as if he had entered another Hogwarts. Everything was eerily familiar.
"Is this where Rowena Ravenclaw's memories are?" Dumbledore asked, watching the students passing by. His expression held genuine surprise.
Harry caught something important in those words.
Whose memories?
Rowena Ravenclaw's?
Could this place be similar to the Pensieve in Dumbledore's office?
He reached out and touched the wall beside him. It was cold to the touch—solid, real.
Tentatively, he approached someone who appeared to be a student. However, as soon as he got close, the person passed straight through him, as if he were a ghost.
But they didn't look like a ghost at all. Ghosts didn't walk—they floated. And they weren't anything but pearly white.
"New boy, watch where you're going," the man said, turning his head with a look of displeasure.
"Sorry," Harry apologized instinctively.
So this really was a memory?
He could hardly believe it. In all the times he had used the Pensieve before, no one had ever been able to see or interact with him, let alone talk to him.
But when he saw Dumbledore's equally surprised expression, he felt reassured. At least he wasn't the only one who had never seen something like this before.
Kyle, on the other hand, remained completely calm, as if this was nothing new to him.
"You can look around as much as you like," Kyle said, walking over to Harry. "There are classrooms upstairs with professors teaching lessons that have existed for centuries. You can sit in and listen if you want."
Harry nodded and set off.
But instead of heading to a classroom, he wandered the castle, much like he had when he first arrived at Hogwarts.
He made his way to the Gryffindor common room, but instead of the familiar Fat Lady, a different painting greeted him—a tall knight wielding a two-handed sword.
The knight refused to let him in because he didn't know the password.
So Harry turned and left, continuing his exploration.
At some point, he found himself in the corridor where the Room of Requirement was located.
He stared at the empty wall for a moment. Then, on a whim, he closed his eyes and began pacing back and forth.
"I need a broom closet... I need a broom closet... I need a broom closet."
He walked three times along the wall, but when he opened his eyes, there was no door.
Right... This is the Room of Requirement. How could there be another Room of Requirement?
Shaking his head, he walked away.
Meanwhile, Dumbledore had also reached the place he was most interested in.
After what felt like three hours—or possibly even longer—the three of them regrouped in the entrance hall, preparing to leave.
"Harry, how was it? Could you understand anything?" Kyle asked.
Harry's face tensed.
"It's... it's fine," he said, though his voice sounded uncertain.
He hadn't even attended the lessons. Well, that wasn't entirely true—he had sat in on one for about ten minutes, but he hadn't understood a word. Eventually, he had slipped out.
That hadn't gone unnoticed. The professor had been furious and had given him an earful for walking out mid-lesson.
Harry had never imagined memories could feel so real. He had subconsciously treated this place like a Pensieve, assuming he could move freely without anyone noticing—leaving whenever he wanted.
That illusion shattered when a book, thrown by an angry professor, passed straight through his head. His legs had nearly given out on the spot.
After that, he had avoided the classrooms entirely, spending the rest of the morning wandering through the castle instead.
Kyle, however, could tell just from Harry's guilty expression what had happened. He didn't press the matter and simply nodded.
He then turned to Dumbledore.
"Very interesting," Dumbledore mused. "This has answered a few mysteries that have puzzled me for years—such as how long the portraits have existed in the school. I have always been curious about that."
But then, his expression shifted slightly. "There is one strange thing, though."
"What is it?" Kyle asked.
"I saw Slytherin in the Chamber of Secrets and Hufflepuff in the kitchens," Dumbledore said. "But I couldn't find Gryffindor anywhere."
Dumbledore's gaze sharpened slightly. "He doesn't seem to be in this castle. But if I remember correctly, Gryffindor was the most active of the Founders. He even served as a professor for a time, teaching students himself."
Kyle hesitated.
He couldn't exactly tell Dumbledore that Godric Gryffindor had been erased from Ravenclaw's memory due to something dishonorable.
Dumbledore is a Gryffindor himself. Would he be able to accept that his house's founder was a man who had been notorious for using his sword to flick at people's belt loops?
What had he even been? A pervert? A weirdo?
For the sake of the Founders' dignity, Kyle chose his words carefully.
"He's probably not at school right now," he said after a pause.
"Really?" Dumbledore didn't dwell on it.
As the three of them stepped out of the Room of Requirement, the door on the wall vanished behind them.
"I heard from Harry that you once transformed his and Malfoy's magic into some sort of animal," Dumbledore said suddenly, glancing at Kyle. "That's how you learned it, isn't it?"
Harry turned toward them as well.
Before, Hermione had said Kyle learned this spell from the library, but now it was clear that wasn't the case.
"That's right," Kyle nodded. "It was in a second-floor Charms class. Professor Lagord thought it was a useful trick."
"It's not a trick," Dumbledore said with a smile. "If you face an opponent unfamiliar with runes, any spell they cast could become an advantage to you. Numbers cease to matter."
He turned, looking at Harry as if about to explain something further. But then, after a brief pause, he chose to say nothing.
Forget it. Some things couldn't be forced.
Harry was doing well enough already. At the very least, he was capable of fighting back against most Death Eaters.